We received this rebuttal from the article appearing in this weeks Arab World, Misinterpreting Islam in the West. We thought it worthy of publishing as this article is totally off base. Read the article here: https://thearabweekly.com/misinterpreting-islam-west and the rebuttal.
Dear Mr. Ghiles,
Thank you for compiling that list of all that’s wrong with Islam in the January 27 edition of The Arab Weekly. You missed only a few points – namely, the Muslims’ refusal to assimilate and the counter-factual Islamic supremacy as expressed in “Allahu Akbar.” The weakness of your complaint that Islam is getting a bum rap is underscored by your reliance on Juan Cole’s laughable assertion that Muhammad was a man of peace. (Just read the 40% One-Star reviews of his book about Muhammad in www.Amazon.com.)
You completely misrepresent Sharia LAW as merely a set of guidance points. It is, in fact, a set of written, indelible, enforceable laws that result stoning of adulterers, wife beating, sexual assault of non-Muslims, honor murders, FGM, and throwing gays off of tall buildings. Sharia Law has no place in any Western country and is categorically opposed to the terms of the U.S. Constitution. Ending the stoning of adulterers would do little to improve the image of Sharia Law which is at its core discriminatory on the basis of race, gender, and religious belief.
You are mistaken about the ignorance of many educated Western people about Islam. When President Thomas Jefferson was faced with the plunder and kidnapping of Americans by the Barbary pirates, he got a copy of the Quran and learned why Muslims considered Americans “sinners” who were fair game for plunder, kidnapping, and rape. Today, as more and more Western communities fall victim to Islamic terrorism, legal jihad, and creeping Sharia, people are reading the unvarnished texts of “Reliance of the Traveler,” the hadith, and the Quran which proclaim, among other things, that non-Muslims are the worst of all creatures, that Sharia Law takes precedence over “man-made laws,” and that Muhammad was victorious through terror.
Hoping that less violence in war-torn Middle East will reduce “Islamophobia,” is a fool’s errand. Most Westerners are indifferent to the internecine conflicts between Sunnis and Shi’ites in the Middle East, the civil war in Syria, and the senseless proxy war in Yemen. What is needed in the West is an end to the rampant illegal immigration, expanding “no-go zones,” and the imposition of Sharia Law mandates on non-Muslims. If there is any basis for “Islamophobia,” it is something that Muslims brought upon themselves.
Please get back to me if you do not understand or do not agree with any of my assertions. I will provide you with the specific references from the Islamic sacred sources.
Chris
and this rebuttal.
Dear Mr. Ghiles,
Thank you for compiling that list of all that’s wrong with Islam in the January 27 edition of The Arab Weekly. You missed only a few points – namely, the Muslims’ refusal to assimilate and the counter-factual Islamic supremacy as expressed in “Allahu Akbar.” The weakness of your complaint that Islam is getting a bum rap is underscored by your reliance on Juan Cole’s laughable assertion that Muhammad was a man of peace. (Just read the 40% One-Star reviews of his book about Muhammad in www.Amazon.com.)
You completely misrepresent Sharia LAW as merely a set of guidance points. It is, in fact, a set of written, indelible, enforceable laws that result stoning of adulterers, wife beating, sexual assault of non-Muslims, honor murders, FGM, and throwing gays off of tall buildings. Sharia Law has no place in any Western country and is categorically opposed to the terms of the U.S. Constitution. Ending the stoning of adulterers would do little to improve the image of Sharia Law which is at its core discriminatory on the basis of race, gender, and religious belief.
You are mistaken about the ignorance of many educated Western people about Islam. When President Thomas Jefferson was faced with the plunder and kidnapping of Americans by the Barbary pirates, he got a copy of the Quran and learned why Muslims considered Americans “sinners” who were fair game for plunder, kidnapping, and rape. Today, as more and more Western communities fall victim to Islamic terrorism, legal jihad, and creeping Sharia, people are reading the unvarnished texts of “Reliance of the Traveler,” the hadith, and the Quran which proclaim, among other things, that non-Muslims are the worst of all creatures, that Sharia Law takes precedence over “man-made laws,” and that Muhammad was victorious through terror.
Hoping that less violence in war-torn Middle East will reduce “Islamophobia,” is a fool’s errand. Most Westerners are indifferent to the internecine conflicts between Sunnis and Shi’ites in the Middle East, the civil war in Syria, and the senseless proxy war in Yemen. What is needed in the West is an end to the rampant illegal immigration, expanding “no-go zones,” and the imposition of Sharia Law mandates on non-Muslims. If there is any basis for “Islamophobia,” it is something that Muslims brought upon themselves.
Please get back to me if you do not understand or do not agree with any of my assertions. I will provide you with the specific references from the Islamic sacred sources.
Chris
